The Trouble with Travel Writing
Posted: April 28, 2012 Filed under: Blogs and Bloggers, change, Hanoi, Reflections, travel | Tags: Hanoi, travel, travel writing, vietnam 1 Comment »
I don’t think that travel writers visiting where you live and airing an opinion is ever a particularly comfortable experience.
Now of course, it’s not a case of someone arriving followed by a wait while they return home and file copy. The writer, whether pro or wannabe, is likely to be sharing their views from the second they hit WIFI. In Vietnam there’s a lot of WIFI.
What it means is that without looking especially hard, you can come across reams and reams of live content generated about where you live. In the end very little of it impresses. Yes it can be mean-spirited to pick holes, but frequently it’s all too easy and that goes for the writers from the quality press just as as much as it does for ambitious young bloggers.
Travel bloggers dreaming of being able to fund an endless holiday, need to be read. In order to be read, even putting aside SEO-thinking, they have to be of use. So instead of actually writing about their travels they write tips for future backpackers. However with limited time in town and limited research resources they Google and cannibalise what they find.
Even their travel writing heroes are not great explorers but great blaggers. Travelling for years fuelled by travel tips churned out and ready to be recycled by the next “nomad”. Sure, it’s not about the destination, it’s the journey. But increasingly it’s length of journey that’s all important.
For the foodies it means visiting that same bun cha restaurant. While those not wanting to be quite so same same, head for the snake village. Another cliche but it’s something to share on YouTube and if it’s good enough for the telly guys… (please, don’t do it).
Meanwhile at the higher end of the market, “proper” journalists descend on Hanoi as the first stop on their tour. All good except they use the same Google as the rest of us. Worse still with flights and rooms arranged by the same PR company the writers ends up staying in the same places and churning out information from the same fact sheets. Google “Charlie Chaplin” AND “Sofitel Metropole” and you get 11,900 results.
After the Metropole there’s the three other hotels that crop up time and time again in Hoi An, Hue and Ho Chi Minh City. One charges well over $1,000 a night. Not the kind of freebie you’re going to slag off in print – then again, with the PRs having primed the resort management it’s not like they’re going to get anything but preferential treatment anyway.
And when did broadsheet travel writing becoming almost exclusively about luxury?
But perhaps the days of The Great Railway Bizarre are over anyway. It’s not just that everyone’s seen it all already on TV and YouTube but travel writing as Paul Theroux said is about “Jumping to conclusions and generalising. Inventing and recreating places from vagrant glimpses.”
In modern times I think we’re less comfortable generalising about people and we’re less comfortable reading those who still do.
That’s probably no bad thing.
I’m not sure where it goes from here though. Are travel tips and Instagrammed photos of sun sets all we have left?
No smiles in Vietnam. Really?
Posted: October 31, 2009 Filed under: Blogs and Bloggers, Hanoi, Reflections | Tags: backpackers, bloggers, laos, smiles, travel writing, vietnam 25 Comments »From Paul Theroux’s Ghost Train to Eastern Star
Most writing about travel takes the form of jumping to conclusions. And so most travel books are superfluous. The thinnest, most transparent monologuing. Little better than a licence to bore. Travel writing is the lowest form of literary self indulgence. Dishonest complaining, creative mendacity, pointless heroics and chronic posturing – much of it distorted with Munchhausen syndrome.
Of course it is much harder to stay at home and be polite to people and face things – but where is the book in that? Better the boastful charade of pretending to be an adventurer. A lusty – “look at me” in exotic landscapes.
***
Little bits of uncompleted life – what the traveller habitually sees – inspires pathos and poetry as well as the maddening sense of being an outsider. Jumping to conclusions and generalising. Inventing and recreating places from vagrant glimpses.
The above passages came back to me as I read Lillie’s “Around the World” blog.
After 6 years teaching public school, I’m traveling around the world for a year (or more!) to write spicy stories.
There’s a reason newspapers are going to the wall. We’re all journalists now. The industry, if not entirely the profession, is de-skilled. That’s generally something I choose to see as a positive thing.
But what Paul Theroux said of travel writing is now truer than ever. You don’t turn up to your potential publishers and have them grill you on where you’ve been and what you’ve written. You just set up a blog and start writing.
On entering Laos, Lillie reflects on Vietnam:
I am confused. What is this strange upward twist of the lips I am seeing here in Laos? I’ve just been in Vietnam for the past month and this expression is unfamiliar. Wait a minute… it’s coming back to me… this expression is known as a “SMILE”! Glory be, Laos is full of them!
Later she adds:
I nearly hugged the waiters when I realized that they could banter. I love bantering! Vietnam does not do banter.
Now, kudos to Laos, but let me assure that Vietnam does both smiles and banter. The pic above is of the staff at Old Quarter hang out Le Pub as they were today – having a blast getting ready for their Halloween party. Banter and smiles aplenty.
Today I had a typical lazy expat Saturday. Swinging between coffee shops – banter and smiles at each.
But what I will admit is this. The conclusion that Lillie has jumped to is not unique. I have read and heard of it before. I have struggled to entirely understand it because I don’t see it. But I will try to make sense of it.
Just for a second put yourselves in the position of the Vietnamese dealing with backpackers. And yes, I mean specifically backpackers.
I used to work in a charity restaurant where the profits went towards keeping street children off the streets. We had a feedback form and would regularly get messages along the lines of – I am just a backpacker your prices are too expensive for me – there should be a special price for backpackers.
The attitude that somehow the backpacker is both victim and the suggested recipient of charity is not unusual. Virtually every time I am in Hanoi’s old quarter I see a backpacker blue in the face and arguing with some local person about a price. Check this also from Lillie.
Now, first of all. The scamming is ridiculous, should be clamped down on and does Vietnam no favours. However backpackers answer me this – how do you bargain without knowing the correct price.?
The truth is you don’t. You can’t. Instead you pay what you can afford. Don’t complain that you were scammed because a) you didn’t know the real price b) you could afford the price suggested and c) you are not very good at bargaining.
The other point about bargaining is this. Bargaining is not them suggesting a price and you calling them a thief and shouting at them. You smile when you bargain. You joke. It’s a dance. It’s flirting. Every transaction should end with both of you smiling.
Get a sense of perspective. If you have an around the world ticket you are not poor. And please..don’t say “but I am on a budget”. If your cash is so short then perhaps your holiday is too long.
Please – don’t lose your temper and write off a whole country as you wave goodbye to a couple of dollars. Just put it down to experience.
As for the people who “serve” you. Can you imagine a succession of backpackers demanding accommodation for under $10 a night but then wanting the earth. Lillie writes:
Sean and I literally investigated 25 hotels over the course of an hour, up and down the sun-glorious, palm-lined main strip of Mui Ne. It was worth it! So what happened? Well, first, everything Lonely Planet suggested was rickety trash. Then, many of the nicer places were a non-negotiable $20 or higher a night: well above of our price cap of $10. Meanwhile, motorbike touts tailed us like wedding car cans, calling, “Come to good hotel! Just six kilometers away!” We declined.
That’s 25 hotels. Can you imagine having that much time? Having that much belief that everywhere was “rickety trash”? Can you imagine what it must be like for the hotel owners to have people turn up and screw their nose up and move on? Do you want them to put their palms together, smile and bow?
(I increasingly think that is exactly what people want in Asia. Sorry but less than $10 on a room doesn’t quite compensate people enough to bow and scrape in the face of open hostility)
So with locals earning a dollar a day faced with backpackers who’ll drink ten dollars a day and still have faces like thunder – well, you can start to understand their point of view. As every local is branded a thief and a scammer it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
And take a look at your fellow backpackers. I see hundreds walking around Hanoi as if they are at the beach. Quite often literally filthy. Can you imagine what it is like having to deal with the unwashed, breezing through your establishments – arguing that they shouldn’t have to pay much because they are “only backpackers” before turning their nose up and trying out the next establishment.
Have some self-awareness. Realise that if you are on such a tight budget then goodwill may not come as part of the package. You’ll have to earn that the old-fashioned way – by treating people with decency and respect. Lillie may not have noticed it but I find nothing works better here than humour and banter.
Additionally try humility. It works well in Vietnam. It works well in travel writing too.
In truth none of us really knows or understands anything here. I’ve spent a total of three years in Vietnam and all I know is I know nothing.
Sometimes, admitting that, is all it takes.


